Vyaya
Side-by-Side Comparison|Updated March 2026

HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition vs ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card

Detailed comparison of fees, rewards, benefits, and value to help you choose the right credit card for your spending pattern.

HDFC Bank

HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition

9.2/10
Annual Fee₹10,000
Base Rewards0.9990000000000001%
NetworkDiners Club
View Full Details

ICICI Bank

ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card

6.5/10
Annual Fee₹2,499
Base Rewards0.25%
NetworkVisa
View Full Details

Feature-by-Feature Comparison

FeatureHDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal EditionICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card
Annual Fee₹10,000₹2,499
Joining Fee₹10,000₹2,499
Fee Waiver Spend₹8,00,000₹2,50,000
Base Reward Rate0.9990000000000001%0.25%
Reward CurrencyReward PointsICICI Reward Points
NetworkDiners ClubVisa
Editor Rating9.2/106.5/10
Forex Markup3.5%3.5%

Accelerated Rewards

HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition

  • 0% on SmartBuy Hotels
  • 0% on SmartBuy Flights
  • 0% on Weekend Dining

ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card

  • 0% on Manchester United Match Days

Pros & Cons

HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition

Pros

  • Unlimited domestic and international lounge access for both primary and add-on cardholders.
  • High base reward rate of 3.33% (5 RP per ₹150) with 1:1 redemption on flights and hotels.
  • Generous quarterly milestone of 10,000 bonus points on ₹4 Lakhs spend.
  • Complimentary annual memberships of Amazon Prime, Swiggy One, and Club Marriott on meeting spend criteria.

Cons

  • Diners Club network acceptance can be lower than Visa/Mastercard in smaller offline stores.
  • No fuel surcharge waiver, which is a downgrade from the plastic version.
  • High annual fee of ₹10,000 with a steep waiver threshold of ₹8 Lakhs.

ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card

Pros

  • Exclusive Manchester United branded welcome gift (Holdall and Football).
  • Accelerated 5 reward points per ₹100 spent on Manchester United match days.
  • Opportunity for top spenders to win a fully paid 'Manchester United Experience' at Old Trafford.
  • 25% discount on movie tickets twice a month on BookMyShow and INOX.

Cons

  • Lounge access requires a high spend of ₹75,000 in the previous calendar quarter.
  • High annual fee of ₹2,499 for a co-branded card with limited non-football benefits.
  • Reward points on rent, fuel, and utilities are heavily restricted or excluded.

Our Verdict

HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition edges ahead overall with a stronger combination of rewards and value. However, ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card could be the better pick if its specific category strengths match your spending habits.

Choose HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition if

Unlimited global lounge access for self and add-on members plus low forex markup.

Choose ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card if

Exclusive access to club merchandise, discounts at the Red Cafe, and chances to visit Old Trafford.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better: HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition or ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card?
HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition edges ahead overall with a stronger combination of rewards and value. However, ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card could be the better pick if its specific category strengths match your spending habits.
What is the annual fee difference between HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition and ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card?
HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition has an annual fee of ₹10,000, while ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card has an annual fee of ₹2,499. HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition offers a fee waiver on ₹8,00,000 annual spend. ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card offers a fee waiver on ₹2,50,000 annual spend.
Which card has better rewards: HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition or ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card?
HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition offers a base reward rate of 0.9990000000000001% with accelerated rewards on SmartBuy Hotels and SmartBuy Flights. ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card offers 0.25% base rewards with bonuses on Manchester United Match Days. The better choice depends on your primary spending categories.
Can I have both HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition and ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card?
Yes, many users hold multiple credit cards to maximize rewards across different spending categories. HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition and ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card can complement each other if they cover different reward categories.
Which card is better for beginners: HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition or ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card?
For beginners, ICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card may be more approachable with a lower annual fee of ₹2,499. However, evaluate based on your expected spending pattern rather than fee alone.

Related Comparisons

HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition vs ICICI Bank Manchester United Platinum Credit CardICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card vs ICICI Bank Manchester United Platinum Credit CardHDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition vs SBI Card ELITEICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card vs SBI Card ELITE

Explore More

HDFC Bank Diners Club Black Metal Edition Full ReviewICICI Bank Manchester United Signature Credit Card Full ReviewAll HDFC Bank CardsAll ICICI Bank CardsBrowse All Credit CardsCredit Card Guides & Tips